Many experiments involving reduction of total caloric intake, in some cases by as much as 70% of ad libitum dietary intake in free-feeding animals, show that calorie restriction improves a number of biomarkers of aging, with overt evidence of improved general health.2-11 The benefits observed in lab animals have also been seen in primates and humans.
As studies over the past two decades defined the beneficial biochemical and physiological effects of calorie restriction, scientists found that a variety of substances, both drugs and natural compounds, could mimic these desirable effects. These so-called “calorie restriction mimetics” have great potential clinical value because very few people can adhere to the degree of calorie restriction that will lead to substantial extension of life.
By the late 1990s, scientists identified a number of compounds that have anti-aging properties as a consequence of their ability to mimic the biological changes associated with caloric restriction.9 These include foods like avocados, nutraceuticals such as resveratrol, carnosine, and acetyl-L-carnitine, herbs such as gymnema and cinnamon, and drugs like metformin and thiazoladinediones.
Use of calorie restriction mimetics, in isolation of significant dietary calorie reduction, has naïve appeal to some people; it looks like an easy option for longevity promotion, but it may not be so. It is much more reasonable to combine calorie restriction mimetics with tolerable but meaningful reductions of overall caloric intake. This approach is deeply rooted in good scientific agreement, derived from almost eight decades of research.1-10
While more research on the use of calorie restriction as a longevity promoter in humans is desirable, the benefits are well documented and highly credible. It certainly warrants consideration if we ever wish to get beyond current futile attempts to reverse the obesity epidemic12.
I believe that use of calorie restriction mimetics in conjunction with calorie restriction diets is central to disease reduction and longevity promotion. It represents the second key component in what I call the “Anti-Aging Triad,” which also includes interventions for stem cell support, and therapies for telomere lengthening (Read Telomeres, Aging & Disease Prevention).
Biological Effects of Calorie RestrictionA simple understanding of the biochemical and physiological effects of calorie restriction explains why this intervention can extend average lifespan. 9,10 There is a major added bonus: Calorie restriction also extends maximum lifespan, defined as the greatest number of years that a living organism can survive.
The biological outcomes of calorie restriction include, but may not be limited to: alteration of the expression and actions of many key enzyme controlling metabolism and protein synthesis; reduction of damaged protein and facilitation of its removal; modulation of normal processes of cell death (apoptosis); modification of the actions of chaperone molecules; reduction in protein/sugar cross-linking (glycosylation); reversal of dysglycemia; reduction of chronic inflammation and inflammatory markers; hormetic effects; inhibition of glycolysis through insulin sensitization; and specific influences on genes that alter cell repair or death (e.g. Sir2 gene or the human homologous SIRT1 gene).13-16
Clinically, we can observe that caloric restriction produces:
- Favorable effects on cardiovascular structure and function, including reduced heart rate, blood pressure, LDL cholesterol, and triglycerides.
- Improvements in insulin sensitivity and normalization of blood glucose.
- Increase in protein synthesis and elimination of abnormal proteins.
- Modulation of the process of “orderly cell death” (apoptosis) with improvement in the repair and maintenance of DNA integrity.
- Reduction of oxidative stress by diminution of free radical generation.
- Reduction in body temperature.
- Reduction in body fat mass, including visceral adiposity, with concomitant increase in muscle mass.
- Beneficial effects on hormonal secretion, particularly on hormones that tend to fall with age, e.g. DHEA and growth hormone.
- Improvements in brain function, including memory, cognition and perhaps mood.
- Spontaneous enhancement of an ability to engage in physical activity.
- Stimulation of growth factors, e.g. BDNF, a nerve growth factor.
- Weight loss
If you’re skeptical, bear in mind that these biochemical and physiological outcomes have been observed in essentially all species of animals that have been subjected to calorie restriction experiments5. Scientists and physicians focused on anti-aging medicine are in agreement that the effects seen in animals are often present in non-human primates and humans5,9.
Calorie Restriction Mimetics
A calorie restriction mimetic is a pharmaceutical or natural compound which has the ability to reproduce one or more principal biological effects of calorie restriction. There are many putative calorie restriction mimetics that are potentially useful in humans.
Some may have primary effects on genetic controls of aging, whereas others may have more specific effects on glucose metabolism. In other words, calorie restriction mimetics show considerable biochemical versatility. There is also a lot of inter-individual and intra-individual variation in the human response to a calorie restriction mimetic.
Calorie restriction produces a highly complex cascade of biological events that match, in part, the even more complicated cascade that regulates aging. I have repeatedly reminded myself and other practitioners of Integrative Medicine that the power of synergy is a pivotal component of natural therapeutics17. It continues to surprise me that many practitioners are using single-supplement interventions, despite the fact that bio-integrative medicine largely rejects the flawed concept of the “single drug, single-receptor action” in therapeutics.
For example, resveratrol—a potent polyphenol found in the skins of red grapes and other plants--has been heralded as a key anti-aging supplement. But it won’t likely lead to optimal outcomes by itself. Resveratrol’s effects are significantly enhanced by the synergistic action of other calorie restriction mimetics, along with dietary changes.
The following table provides a list of calorie restriction mimetics supported by credible science showing biological effects in animals and/or humans.13-19
Metformin: A drug that increases insulin sensitivity, reduces gluconeogenesis, inhibits excessive glucose absorption, enhances glycolysis secondary to increased expression of genes encoding for glucokinase and liver-specific pyruvate kinase. Modulates stress responses, with the activation of AMPK.
Resveratrol* : A plant polyphenol that stimulates Sir2 gene, reducing or modulating apoptosis. Proven anticancer benefits with beneficial cardiovascular effects, including potent antioxidant activity. Effects on apoptosis are complex, operating through mechanisms of hormesis, dependent on the ratio of resveratrol to other related molecules that alter “pro and anti-apoptotic” factors.
Carnosine*: A combination of amino acids, which inhibits cross-linking of proteins and formation of harmful AGE’s (advanced glycosylation end-products). Enhances glutamate action in the brain, stimulating nitric oxide with improvement in brain function and memory. A classic anti-aging factor that increases average lifespan, but not maximum lifespan in rodents. Arguably a calorie restriction mimetic, carnosine has potential synergy with other natural anti-aging compounds.
Avocado*: Mannoheptulose from avocado improves insulin sensitivity and blood glucose levels, with thermogenic effects on fat deposits in muscle. Enhances lifespan in mice.
Gymnema*: Alkaloids (gymnemosides) from this herb have glucose regulating effects.
2-Deoxyglucose: Increases insulin sensitivity & reduces blood glucose, but is toxic at high doses. Not recommended for routine use because of narrow window of safety versus therapeutic effect.
Aminoguanidine: Reduces abnormal protein accumulation, prevents glycosylation and reduces AGEs.
Hydroxycitrate: May reduce caloric intake. Not recommended for clinical use because of liver toxicity.
Adiponectin: Plays a role in fat metabolism, perhaps mediating the effects of calorie restriction.
Thiazolidinediones: Insulin-sensitizing drugs, but with limited utility owing to variable and onerous side effects.
Iodoacetate: Prevents the ill effects of toxic glucose metabolites.
Exandin: A glucagon-like-peptide (GLP) which counteracts the effects of glucagon, reduces plasma glucose, and suppresses food intake.
PYY3-36: A peptide gut hormone that inhibits food intake via actions on the hypothalamus, with secondary effects on glucose metabolism.
Leptin: Stimulates fat metabolism and reduces body weight. Involved in hormonal responses triggered by calorie restriction. May be a principal mediator of the clinical effects of calorie restriction.
Alpha Lipoic Acid*: Valuable antioxidant with insulin sensitizing actions.
Cinnamon*: Methylhydroxychalones in cinnamon are insulin mimetics.
Acetyl-L-Carnitine*: Antioxidant with neuroprotective and energizing effects. May not be a calorie restriction mimetic by strict definition, but facilitates mitochondrial function.
Mixed Antioxidants*: While not calorie restriction mimetics per se, grape seed extract, mixed polyphenols, green tea polyphenols, ellagic acid, and maritime pine bark are antioxidants with specific anticancer and cardiovascular effects. Cancer and cardiovascular disease are the two major causes of premature death.
The asterisk (*) denotes good scientific agreement on use as nutritional support, with evidence of safety and efficacy in producing physiologic and biochemical changes typically associated with calorie restriction.
A Novel Anti-Aging Strategy
Longevity is unquestionably the legacy of positive and healthy lifestyle. Anti-aging or “regenerative” medicine must be defined within the context of advanced preventive medicine. At the same time, it is important to realize that prevention or reduction in prevalence of premature causes of death and disability may not have as significant an impact on average and maximum lifespan as has been hitherto supposed. We physicians need to pair efforts at prevention of fatal illness with promotion of well-being!
The combined use of several dietary supplements that have additive calorie restriction mimetic effects, in conjunction with appropriate lifestyle and dietary changes can go a long way in meeting both of those clinical goals.
I am not optimistic that major reduction in daily caloric intake is a widely achievable intervention for most people in industrialized societies like the US, where high-calorie, low nutrient foods are plentiful, cheap and ubiquitous.
Consequently, the availability of natural substances that reproduce the physiological effects of calorie restriction is a major advance in the anti-aging field.
My recommendations would include the synergistic use of supplements such as carnosine, resveratrol, gymnema alkaloids, and alpha lipoic acid, as well as foods like cinnamon and avocado. Grape seed extracts, ellagic acid, and pine bark polyphenols give added benefits. These mimetics should be used in the context of a healthy diet with tolerable but meaningful limitations on total caloric intake. Bear in mind that these compounds all have potentially beneficial effects beyond their ability to mimic the effects of calorie restriction.
We certainly need longitudinal studies to assess the benefits of calorie restriction mimetics, but it may take many years before what now seems obvious clinically becomes apparent in “hard-nosed” scientific language. With the prevalence of obesity, diabetes, heart disease and other chronic diseases as high as they are at present, I don’t think we can afford to wait for “definitive” clinical trials. In treating patients, we need all the help we can get, and we need it now!
Stephen Holt, MD, PhD, is the founder and scientific advisor of Natural Clinician, LLC (www.naturalclinician.com). He is a widely recognized researcher, clinician, lecturer and author of many scientific papers and books. This article, the second in a series on regenerative medicine, is based on a keynote speech presented at The American Academy For Anti-Aging Medicine’s Annual Congress. The topic of calorie restriction mimetics is explored in detail in Dr. Holt’s new book entitled, "The Anti-Aging Triad."
1. Holt S. Specific anti-aging factors for natural clinicians, Townsend Letter, July 2008, 90-96.
2. Roth GS, Ingram DK, Lane M. Calorie restriction in primates: will it work and how will we know? J Am Ger Soc, 1999, 47:896-903.
3. Spindler ST. Calorie restriction enhances the expression of key metabolic enzymes associated with protein renewal during aging, Ann NY Acad Sci, 2001, 928:296-304.
4. Lee CK, Klopp RG, Weindruch R. Gene expression of aging and its retardation by calorie restriction, Science 1999, 285(5432):1390-1393.
5. Walford R, Harris SB, Gunion MW. The calorically-restricted, low fat nutrient-rich diet in Biosphere-2 significantly lowers blood glucose, total leukocyte count, cholesterol and blood pressure in humans, Proc Natl Acad Sci. 1992, 89:11533-11537.
6. Cao SX, Dhahbi JM, Mote PL. Genomic profiling of short- and long-term calorie restriction effects in the liver of aging mice. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2001, 98(19):10630-5
7. Cusi K, De Fronzo RA. Metformin: a review of its metabolic effects. Diabetes Rev 1998, 6(2):89-131
8. Dhahbi JM, Mote PL, Wingo J et al. Calories and aging alter gene expression for gluconeogenic, glycolytic and nitrogen metabolising enzymes. Am J Physiol 1999, 277(2:1): E352-360.
9. Kyriazis M. Anti Aging Medicines, Watkins Publishing, London, UK , 2005.
10. Walford RL. The 120 Year Diet: How To Double Your Vital Years, Simon & Schuster, New York, New York, 1986.
11. Roth GS, Ingram D, Lane MA. Caloric restriction in primates and relevance to humans. Ann NY Acad Sci, 2001, 928:305-315.
12. Holt S. Combat Syndrome X, Y and Z, Wellness Publishing, Little Falls, NJ, 2003.
13. Ingram DK, Anson RM et al. Development of calorie restriction mimetics as a prolongevity strategy, Ann N Y Acad Sci, 2004, 1019:412-423.
14. Lane MA, Mattison J, et al. Calorie restriction and aging in primates: relevance to humans and possible CR mimetics, Microsc Res Tech, 2002, 59:335-338
15. Hursting SD, Lavigne JA, et al. Calorie restriction, aging and cancer prevention: mechanisms of action and applicability to humans, Ann Rev Med, 2003, 54:131-52.
16. Wood JG, Rogina B, Lavu S, et al, Sirtuin Activators mimic calorie restriction and delay aging in metazoans, Nature, 2004, 430:686-689.
17. Holt S. A Primer of Natural Therapeutics, a Certification Course for Dietary Supplement Counselors, Holt Institute of Medicine Press, Little Falls, NJ, 2008
18. Quideau S. Plant “polyphenolic” small molecules can induce a calorie restriction-mimetic lifespan extension by activating sirtuins, ChemBioChem, 2004, 5(4):427-430.
19. Dhahbi JM, Mote PL, et al. Identification of potential caloric restriction mimetics by microarray profiling, Physio Genomics, 2005, 23:343-350.
20. Holt S. Natural therapeutics: observations on multivitamins, Townsend Letter, Feb/Mar 2009
21. Evans W, Rosenberg IH, Biomarkers: The 10 Determinants of Aging You Can Control, New York, NY 1991.
22. Klatz R, The Official Anti-Aging Revolution, Basic Health Publications, Laguna Beach, CA, 2007.
23. Weindruch R, Keenan KP, Carney JM, et al, Caloric restriction mimetics, J Geron, 2001, 56:20-33.